- Business Insider exclusively reports that French media and advertising groups are calling on Apple to disable its new Distraction Control feature.
- They claim that new iPhone tools can interfere with websites and ads.
- The organizations said in the letter that they are “actively considering all available legal resources.”
A group of French industry associations representing around 800 companies in the advertising and media sector has written an open letter to Apple CEO Tim Cook, demanding that the tech giant implement a new iPhone feature called “distraction control.” We asked them to stop the deployment.
Distraction controls, available in iOS 18 this fall, allow users of the iPhone’s Safari browser to hide elements on web pages, such as images, pop-ups, and ads. It then remembers those requests when the user revisits that page. However, Apple says it won’t permanently hide website elements that change frequently (such as ads).
In a letter sent Thursday, a copy of which was seen by Business Insider, the French industry group cited three main concerns about the feature after beta and public testing. .
Apple did not respond to a request for comment.
The group said in the letter that users could potentially hide a website’s consent management platform (the technology that drives the cookie consent pop-up), which could cause site owners to not comply with Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation. They have raised concerns that they may be at risk.
This could also hinder publishers’ profits, they said in the letter. European media companies are increasingly asking users to agree to serve personalized ads (which are generally more profitable than non-targeted ads) or to pay a fee to access their content. .
The French industry group also said in a letter that what the tests found was true in some cases. all Ads on a particular website are now hidden when a user opts out of ads on one page of the site.
The letter says this poses “an existential threat to the online advertising model that underpins a critical part of the Internet economy.”
Finally, the letter states that by allowing users to hide any content on a web page, especially editorial content produced by news organizations, distracting controls will increase the risk of “information manipulation” and the spread of information on the Internet. states that it has the potential to promote
While it’s possible to manipulate web pages using image editing tools, distraction controls make it much easier to remove, screenshot, and share specific content with a tap. said Pierre Devoize, deputy managing director of digital marketing organization Alliance Digitale. One of the industry groups that co-signed the letter.
The letter includes Alliance Digitale, press organization Alliance de la Presse d’Information Générale, online publishing association Geste, advertising agency association Syndicat des Régies Internet, advertising association Union des Marques, and media buying and planning union UDECAM. Co-signed. Agency.
The letter asks Apple to pause the rollout of Distraction Control and provide technical documentation about its features and planned updates.
“We are actively considering all available legal resources” related to data protection, press freedom, intellectual property rights, copyright and trademark law, and competition regulation, the group said in the letter. states.
The letter was also copied to several French ministers, the French Competition Authority and the European Commission.
Publishers and advertising companies have been affected by Apple’s software updates in the past.
Earlier this year, the same French group raised concerns with Apple over reports of a promising feature called “Web Eraser,” worrying it could hurt advertising revenue.
The letter was in response to a report from. AppleInsider Citing people familiar with the matter, the magazine said the planned feature would allow Safari users to delete content and make the browser aware of that choice, a description that is distracting. Very similar to controls. The News Media Association, a British publishing group, also sent a letter to Apple warning that such tools threaten the financial sustainability of journalism.
AppleInsider later reported that Apple changed the feature’s name from Web Eraser to Distraction Control and updated it to include a pop-up explaining that it “does not permanently remove ads.”
Publishers and advertising companies have been hit hard by Apple’s software updates in the past. The 2021 App Tracking Transparency update required app owners to get explicit permission from users before tracking their apps across other apps and websites. Most users opted out of tracking, making it difficult for developers such as media publishers to monetize their apps.
This was followed in 2017 by another sweeping privacy change, Intelligent Tracking Prevention, which disabled the use of third-party tracking cookies in the Safari browser by default. Almost immediately after the rollout, publishers and ad tech companies reported reductions in CPM, the cost of targeting 1,000 impressions.